Should you apply for your MBA in round 2 or wait for next cycle?

Round 2 deadlines are in less than two months. I typically recommend at least four months to build strong applications, but ideally six. It is not impossible to apply within two months, but the conditions need to be right. These are the questions I often ask applicants to figure out if now is their time.
What does success look like for you?
Do you prefer to go to the best possible school you can, or do you prefer to go sooner, even if it may not be your top choice or the most competitive program? If the goal is to go to, say, Harvard Business School or another M7 program, then I recommend applying when you are going to be the best applicant you can be, which may not be right now, depending on your answers to the other questions below. If you are relatively flexible on which school, then a faster turnaround may work for you.
What is the status of your GMAT or GRE?
If you are just starting to study for the GMAT or GRE, then you will likely need more than two months to hit your best. Have you taken a diagnostic exam? Do you know how far you have to go? Or, if you have been working on testing for a few months now, are you consistently hitting a competitive score on practice exams? Are you ready to take a test, or two, or three, or would you be rushing to take a test before you are ready, simply because you are up against deadlines? Would you end up with a score that reflects your best, or would it be just the best you can do under current time constraints? (If you are wondering whether another sitting is worth it, here is why there is rarely a downside to retesting.)
Have you aligned with recommenders?
Two months is really the minimum amount of time I like to give to recommenders. They need time to build strong recommendations that represent the strengths we want to showcase. Holidays can often get in the way during round 2, so it is important to connect with recommenders and see if they are truly able to dedicate time and thought to building strong recommendations.
Would you have extra time to invest in essays?
Essays are already quite time consuming, and with fewer weeks between now and deadlines, they will require more bandwidth than usual. In a recent client survey, my clients reported spending 5 to 15 hours per week on our process. Those who worked on it over more months skew toward the lower end, and those who work on a condensed timeline are on the higher end. Keep in mind that if you are still testing, your studying and essays might compete for your time. If you wait and apply in round 1, starting around February or so, you could finish your testing first and not let applications distract you from hitting your highest possible score.
Have you been engaging with schools?
Applicants who attend events, connect with admissions committee members, and speak with students and alumni can very clearly speak to who they would be in the program and why that program is the perfect fit for them. If you have already been doing this work, you may be ready to apply in round 2. If not, it may be difficult to engage during the Thanksgiving to New Year’s period, when students are taking final exams and staff are getting ready to be out for the holidays.
What would the next 8 to 10 months look like before round 1 applications?
Will something change at work over the next year? Would you be in the same role, or would you grow in some way? If nothing much will change, then there is a benefit to leaving for business school sooner to continue growing in a different way. What do you gain by waiting, beyond the potential for a stronger application and admissions outcome? Can you use your time valuably? This could look like not only growth at work, but also more school research and being more deliberate about how you arrive at business school, getting more involved in your extracurriculars, or taking on more mentorship opportunities at work.
How do you feel about a two-year strategy and being a reapplicant?
Some applicants choose to take a bit more risk, and invest their time and resources into the process now, despite potential hurdles, to see where it goes. If it turns out well, they get to go to business school a year earlier, and if it doesn’t work out, they then reapply to a broader set of schools in year two. Other applicants do not want to go through the process twice, and would rather apply in the cycle when they know they are the best possible candidate they can be.
Is there a time-sensitive reason to start your MBA sooner?
Are you near the top of the age range? Is your role ending? Do you have a partner who needs to move cities now? Do you have a visa concern? There are a number of reasons that make it beneficial to go to business school sooner. We often share them with admissions committees so they understand why you are applying now rather than next year.
What about round 3?
Applicants sometimes ask “what about round 3?” My answer is that it really depends and can vary year to year. Most top schools try to fill their classes in rounds 1 and 2. In round 3, you are subject to whichever schools happen to have space left, versus approaching them in round 1, when all seats are open. On top of that, you will likely be a stronger candidate in round 1, when you have had more time for testing and applications. So if now is your year and you are flexible on school choices, round 3 could work, but if you have your heart set on a certain school or a small subset, round 3 may disappoint.
So, should you apply now or wait?
Is it too late to apply in round 2? Not necessarily. If your test score already reflects your best, your recommenders have the time, and you have been engaging with schools, two months can be enough. If several of those pieces are still open, waiting for round 1 of the next cycle will usually make you a stronger applicant.
Most of the time I find myself telling applicants to slow down, because round 1 is not a shortcut and neither is a rushed round 2. However, the right answer depends on your own mix of these factors, and for some people the answer is actually to apply now.

